Conference vote leaves Lib Dems facing both ways on Bedroom Tax


“So what’s new?” you’re probably thinking.

Well, the passing of the motion to condemn the Bedroom Tax as official Liberal Democrat policy indicates that there is a huge rift between the way grassroots Lib Dems think and what the Parliamentary Party is doing.

But is it enough to force a split in the Coa-lamity – sorry, Coalition – before the next election, as Vince Cable has hinted?

Who knows? It’s the Lib Dems.

It could indicate that time is running out for the ‘Orange Book’ Liberal Democrats, who include Nick Clegg and Danny Alexander among their number – despite claims by the Daily Telegraph that they have become more influential.

My brother, the blogger beastrabban, told me of a recent conversation between a friend of his and a former Liberal Democrat MP, in which the ex-Hon Gentleman made his opinion of the Orange Bookers – the party’s right-wingers – perfectly clear: “They’re not Liberal”.

This certainly seems to be the feeling of the party’s rank-and-file. Julie Porksen, the Northumbrian member who tabled the Bedroom Tax motion, said: “We are Liberal Democrats and we do not kick people when they are down.”

This may have come as quite a shock to Messrs Clegg, Alexander, David Laws (editor of the Orange Book) and their nearly-Tory buddies, who have been merrily kicking people when they were down ever since they decided they weren’t going to abolish student fees after all, but would help the Tories increase them instead.

Since then, Parliamentary Liberal Democrats have helped force some of the worst injustices of modern times onto the British people, including the Health and Social Care Act, the Welfare Reform Act, the Jobseekers (Back to Work Schemes) Act, the Localism Act and, yes, the Bedroom Tax.

Nick Clegg is clearly a long, long way out of touch with his members. All he could say about it at conference was that “you would have to be made of granite” not to have feelings on the issue.

Would he commit to changing it? No.

So it seems the Liberal Democrat leader is refusing to carry out the will of his party. I wonder what they’re going to do about it?

One way Clegg could save his career might be to bring the Coalition to an early end, as suggested by Vince Cable at a fringe event arranged by the Independent.

But it seems likely Cable was just causing mischief. “It is obviously a very sensitive one. It has got to be led by the leader,” he said.

Again, this would put Clegg in a very awkward position. Splitting the Coalition means giving up the only power or influence he is ever likely to have.

At the end of the day, it’s not going to make much real difference. After the 2015 election his party will probably have fewer MPs than the DUP, if local election results are any indication. He must take responsibility for that – his leadership is bringing his party to the brink of oblivion.

Nick Robinson’s speculation that Clegg could jump from coalition with Cameron to an alliance with Ed Miliband is, therefore, premature.

But there’s another Liberal Democrat conference to come before the general election. Maybe, by then, Nick Clegg will have grasped that he needs to put his party’s best interests before his own ambitions.

latest video

news via inbox

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


  1. beetleypete September 18, 2013 at 12:31 pm - Reply

    Clegg is a weasel, and the Liberals deserve everything they get. Hopefully, they will disappear from the political map of the UK after 2015, and just be an unfortunate memory. They have all ‘played along’, and we know what we think of the ‘just following orders’ defence!
    Lets hope that Miliband doesn’t do a pre-election deal with whoever is in charge of them next time. If the Scots go for independence, he will need to make up the shortfall of Scottish Labour MP’s from somewhere…
    Cheers Mike, Pete.

  2. russell johnson September 18, 2013 at 12:34 pm - Reply

    there used to be a saying thst the liberals were the most promising party in the country, because they’d never get elected to power. now that they have ‘power’ they have been found out.

    • Ann Mulqueen September 19, 2013 at 3:17 pm - Reply

      The Lib/Dems joining the Conservative Party was a bit of a clue!

  3. jaynel62 September 18, 2013 at 12:35 pm - Reply

    Maybe by the next LibDem Conference Clegg won’t be the Leader? – One can Hope :-)

  4. Denise Clendinning September 18, 2013 at 1:30 pm - Reply

    Maybe he is servicing his own interest,s and is in bed with Cameron and he is giving the impression he care,s but to be truthful he is finished and i will be glad to see the back of him. He is Tory through and through and i hope he does,nt get to upset when he has to give the jag back.

  5. Kevin Leonard September 18, 2013 at 2:07 pm - Reply

    Sadly this odious of leaders will not fade away into the back ground but will take up his position of power created for him by Cameron as reward for his treachery be it in the house of Frauds or over in Brussels

  6. Thomas M September 18, 2013 at 4:58 pm - Reply

    He can’t repeat what he did before if he ends up with few or no MPs. If he’s not careful, his own party will crumble to dust.

  7. […] "So what's new?" you're probably thinking. Well, the passing of the motion to condemn the Bedroom Tax as official Liberal Democrat policy indicates that there is a huge rift between the way grassro…  […]

  8. Jane Anderson September 19, 2013 at 10:22 am - Reply

    Hopefully Lib Dem members will now leave in droves to dissociate themselves from the embarrassing conference. their power-crazed leadership and this evil Government.

  9. […] It is too little, too late from the Party that Likes to Change its Mind – and one must question the timing. The newspaper states that “the Liberal Democrat conference agreed to review the bedroom tax” in September last year, but this is inaccurate; the conference passed a motion that official Liberal Democrat policy must be condemnation of the Bedroom Tax. […]

Leave A Comment