Hypocritical Tories try gaslighting us with foodbank photocalls – but is something more serious behind it?
What is going on at the Trussell Trust?
Britain’s biggest food bank charity was once one of the wolves at the Tory government’s door; now it seems to be Theresa May’s poodle.
Has it been nobbled with another of the Tories’ famous gagging contracts, in which charities are blackmailed into promising not to criticise or embarrass the government or face the loss of funding? That seems possible – the Conservatives were threatening it, way back in 2014.
As Mrs May and her vile government of the privileged stares into the abyss being opened up by their failure of a Brexit deal, down which their support is likely to fall, it seems clear that they need to build up their profile if they are to have any chance at all in a snap general election.
So a series of photo opportunities in which MPs like Dominic Raab, Claire Perry, Ross Thomson and Stephen Crabb pretend to care about the people their policies have forced into food poverty – most obviously wherever Universal Credit has been rolled out – presumably seems a worthwhile wheeze. And Tesco seems to be getting a lot of free advertising from it!
We all need to be aware that they aren’t showing they care about us.
They’re taking the piss out of the poor – and they’re doing it to a script:
If you want to give the impression you've spontaneously donated to a food bank, probably best not to mostly copy and paste whatever the Scottish Tory PR office sent over… pic.twitter.com/oBVoXAMaie
— Steph Paton 🇵🇸 (@stephenpaton134) December 2, 2018
Click on the images in the tweet above to see a series of identical tweets from Conservative MPs working to that script.
But if they think we’re too stupid to see through this grotesque attempt at gaslighting, they need to think again. Witness:
Tory mps visiting foodbanks and gloating. They'll be dancing on our graves if they had the chance. Those of us that can afford a funeral that is. We aren't your poverty porn. #StopUniversalCredit #StopandScrapUniversalCredit #stopkillingpeople
— Charlotte Hughes. The Poor Side Of life (@charlotteh71) December 1, 2018
Charlotte, who writes the Poor Side of Life blog which features true stories of people living at the sharp end of cruel Conservative policies that are geared towards harming the poor, also tweeted:
If a tory politician would wanted to take a photo next to the food parcels that I hand out I'd tell them to do one. They chose to starve people. They're killing people. Remind them this at every opportunity.
— Charlotte Hughes. The Poor Side Of life (@charlotteh71) December 1, 2018
Hasan Patel told us:
Tory MP’s taking pictures at foodbank collections is like your landlord taking pictures with the residents he just evicted.
— Hasan Patel 🌹 (@CorbynistaTeen) December 2, 2018
Video legend EL4JC stated:
This will be forever known as the weekend when Tories paraded their callous hypocrisy by tweeting from food banks and the Daily Mail called for a “volunteer NHS army” as the Centrists lapped it all up….
— EL4C (@EL4JC) December 2, 2018
Ray Tallis pointed out:
There has been an epidemic of Tory MPs this weekend visiting food banks for photo-opportunities choreographed by Central Control. Presumably the aim is to make them seem like human beings. People aren't stupid: they know Tory heartlessness caused food poverty.
— Ray Tallis (@ProfRayTallis) December 2, 2018
Clare Hepworth directly addressed prime minister Theresa May:
MEMO to the PM
Theresa – don't you think it's beyond obscene – that your Tory MPs are engaging in PR stunts using food banks ?
Is this your notion of dealing with *burning injustices* ?
Visit the victims of Tory policies & have your photo taken whilst smiling broadly ?#Shameful— Clare Hepworth OBE (@Hepworthclare) December 1, 2018
She added, more generally:
I am NOT a violent woman !
But the sight of Tory politicians being photographed alongside food banks
makes me incandescent with RAGE !!
They have to GO !!— Clare Hepworth OBE (@Hepworthclare) December 1, 2018
Individual MPs came in for specific criticism, including Stephen Crabb:
Stephen Crabb MP is a prime example. He always turns up at photo opportunities with @PATCHcharity (our local foodbank) https://t.co/G2CzLqTMRi
— Olivia Atkinson (@AtkinsonOlivia) December 2, 2018
Dominic Raab set himself up for particularly harsh – and totally deserved – criticism:
Thank you to Tesco in Molesey and the Trussell Trust for partnering to encourage customers to generously provide food collections for families in our community, who are struggling at this time of year. pic.twitter.com/QkuCgQ8qAl
— Dominic Raab (@DominicRaab) November 30, 2018
In response, David Schneider tweeted: “In predictable news, man who failed to realise we’re an island fails to realise connection between Tory policy and the poverty caused by Tory policy.
John Clarke suggested: “Alternative Headline: ‘Dominic Raab thanks turkeys for voting for Christmas!’ Dominic added: “Thank you, turkeys, I mean that most sincerely. No need for you to thank us humans for providing you with warm accommodation and a painless death at this time of year.”
Rachel Clarke (I have no idea if they’re related, although I doubt it) pointed to the facts: “Mr Raab, you cannot be unaware that the Trussell Trust’s own stats show >50% increase in food bank use in areas where universal credit was rolled out. Your policies have *created* this crisis and your faux concern is the height of hypocrisy.”
Libelling Tory misandrist Claire Perry, who falsely accused Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn of anti-Semitism and regularly accuses men who take a different opinion from her own of “mansplaining”, was out opening a food bank in Devizes. She never thought for a moment that the opening of a food bank is no cause for joy. Fortunately James Colwell was available to explain – not “mansplain” – it to her:
https://twitter.com/J_A_Colwell/status/1069143080178200578
Dave Ward added: “Look at the state of this. A Tory MP smiles as she opens a foodbank. A true measure of an improving society would be closing foodbanks not opening them. They truly have no shame.”
Woflie wondered: “Doesn’t Claire Perry realise that every food bank that opens is proof that the Tory Government is failing? Is she really that stupid?”
Answers please to .@claireperrymp on Twitter.
And Frances Ryan, who writes so movingly about the Tories’ benefit brutality, added: “Tories having a brilliant time at food banks is my new obsession.”
It was up to Steve Peers to make the obvioius overarching point – and he made it well:
Good Lord. The "Tory MP food bank photo opportunities" tweets are actually copying a script. The only photo that could leave a positive impression is a Tory MP with a food bank closing due to a genuine lack of need for it. https://t.co/vGdlXSR1Xt
— Steve Peers (@StevePeers) December 2, 2018
“The only photo that could leave a positive impression is a Tory MP with a food bank closing due to a genuine lack of need for it.”
So these food bank photo op Tories have all failed.
Instead of making themselves look like champions of the people, they have drawn attention to their own heartlessness.
Related to this is the emergence of new Tory general election candidates. Put this together with the food bank photo opportunities and it suggess they have to be getting ready for something – right?
Congratulations to @LauraWirral who has been chosen to fight the seat of Wirral West, and @KimCaddy selected as our new @Conservatives candidate for Battersea. I know both will work incredibly hard for their communities and make excellent MPs. pic.twitter.com/p9tiZW6sgd
— Theresa May (@theresa_may) December 2, 2018
The Labour Whips’ Twitter feed came out with the obvious: “Nothing to see here, just Theresa May and the Tories getting ready for that General Election she says won’t happen…”
But here’s a thing: Commentators across the mainstream media are telling us that, even if Mrs May loses a vote on her rubbish Brexit deal, she won’t lose the “no confidence” vote that the Labour Party will inevitably demand afterwards.
If that were true, we would not be seeing this attempt to charm the public.
I would certainly advise constituency Labour parties to make sure they have a prospective Parliamentary candidate in place. If this means deselecting one of the centrists who have been such a hindrance to Labour since 2015, they need to get on with it now.
It would be grimly humorous if the Tory attempt at jollying up the public was what alerted us to their election plans.
Trussell trust have apparently told our local council of churches they are “opening here soon”, which has resulted in several churches withdrawing food collection points from the only food bank we have .
Just before Christmas, just as UC is rolled out in our constituency. When demand is rocketing and donations are falling .
What is going on?
trussel trust charges for its services nothing is free
Evidence that tories have no compassion for people on low incomes is rife, but this surely is top of the list.
Frankly when you consider it all over the last 8yrs Genocide is Con’s political choice.😕
Tories are just cruel and evil bullies.
I volunteer at an independent foodbank (not Trussell) and the Tories would not be welcome there. If any of them did dare come I would have to be physically restrained.
I saw the one from our “gift that keeps on giving”, Ross Thomson, yesterday. I didn’t realise it was a multi-Tory, HQ-led project. I should have known that Ross would never have the savvy to think it up himself.
Not Tesco Galashiels by the way. Maybe Hawick to be pedantic.
Trophy hunters posing with their kill
People donating food for the hungry and others volunteering their time to distribute it is the very core of socialism, something the Tories hate when it’s not state money going to the rich. So for Tories to bask in socialism when they caused the hunger suggests they fear a snap election in which their cruelty will be savaged. If ordinary people had not intervened these past eight years thousands would have died of malnutrition.
The article starts with a dig at Trussell, but doesn’t carry this through. Perhaps the writer belatedly realised charities need to avoid being blatantly party political?
There’s no evidence ‘centrists’ are the cause of Labour’s failure to win the last GE, or to pull ahead of this useless government in the polls. That’s down to the Dear Leader, his Brexit beliefs, and the largely useless team he’s gathered round him. The idea that the best reaction to an iimpending surprise GE is to defenestrate sitting lie popular) elected MPs is barking mad.
The then head of the Trussell Trust reported in 2014, that in 2013 he was “warned by “someone in power” to stop attacking the benefits system or “the Government might try to shut you down”. So in order to keep providing for people in need they have had to tome down their criticism. https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/foodbank-charity-threatened-closure-government-3682914