Trident debate reveals faults of UK’s ‘independent’ nuclear deterrent

160718 trident rising cost

It runs on an obsolete version of Windows and creates work for the USA rather than the UK, but the Tories – and Slick Owen Smith – want to keep it, just in case they feel the need to commit genocide.

That’s what This Writer found out in advance of the Commons vote on Trident, called by Theresa May, today (Monday, July 18).

The motion, couched in overcomplicated language, comes down to this: “The Commons support the Conservative Government’s assessment that it is essential to keep Trident ‘for as long as the global security situation demands’ [an interesting and arbitrary choice of words!] to deter the most extreme threats to the UK’s national security and way of life and that of the UK’s allies; supports the decision to maintain this situation by replacing the current extremely expensive submarines with four new, extremely expensive submarines; recognises the importance of this programme to the UK’s defence industry, and in supporting thousands of engineering jobs [all but 520 of which are based in America]; notes that the government will provide annual reports to Parliament; recognises that the UK is committed to reducing its nuclear weapons stockpile by the mid-2020s; and supports the government’s commitment to continue work towards a safer and more stable world [seriously, this is in the motion], pressing for… multilateral disarmament.”

The motion could seriously harm the Labour leadership election prospects of Slick Owen Smith, who quite clearly told Andrew Marr yesterday (Sunday) not only that he believed in nuclear disarmament but that the UK needed its nuclear weapons to achieve this, but also that – if he was asked to do it – he would certainly press the nuclear button an “annihilate millions of people”.

What a nice guy!

The best that can be said about Slick Owen’s view is this:

160718 trident mass suicide

If you want to know the effects of a Trident detonation near your home, visit this site, drag the red marker to your town, set it for a Trident detonation and see how many of your immediate family would survive (quick answer: none).

Let’s move on to jobs.

In fact, Trident supports just 520 jobs in Faslane, Scotland. Here’s an infographic about it:

160718 trident did you know

If you still don’t believe that Trident doesn’t employ thousands of people here, but does so in the USA, see this:

160718 trident UK jobs

Finally, you’ll be interested to know that Trident runs on an obsolete version of Microsoft Windows – Windows XP (or, amusingly, Windows for Submarines).

160718 trident windows xp

By now, you may be feeling distinctly less secure about Trident than you were at the start of this article. It isn’t just about the cost; it’s about the whole package.

And if you’re still undecided, let’s end on a handy little list of Trident problems (created before George Osborne was sacked):

160718 trident defies logic

So, what do you think? Is Trident worth it? Or is it just an extremely expensive ego-boost for politicians like Slick Owen Smith, who think being able to kill millions makes them special?


Join the Vox Political Facebook page.

If you have appreciated this article, don’t forget to share it using the buttons at the bottom of this page. Politics is about everybody – so let’s try to get everybody involved!

Vox Political needs your help!
If you want to support this site
but don’t want to give your money to advertisers)
you can make a one-off donation here:

Donate Button with Credit Cards

Buy Vox Political books so we can continue
fighting for the facts.

Health Warning: Government! is now available
in either print or eBook format here:

HWG PrintHWG eBook

The first collection, Strong Words and Hard Times,
is still available in either print or eBook format here:


2 thoughts on “Trident debate reveals faults of UK’s ‘independent’ nuclear deterrent

  1. Jessie

    I cannot express sufficiently my disgust at the derisory way many Labour MPs treated their leader (a far better, HONEST and more decent human being than they will ever be), during the Trident debate.

    If they are voting in the same way as the Tories on everything, how can they carry on about how they need to get rid of Corbyn in order to become a viable opposition again?!

    They should move across to the Tory benches where they belong.

    They must be deselected.

    So giving the SNP good cause to claim that they are becoming the real opposition party.

Comments are closed.