Tory double standards: Abuse them and the police are called – but they can abuse anyone freely
Conservative MPs have been at their abusive worst in Parliament – heckling Speaker John Bercow over his decision to allow a vote on the so-called Grieve Amendment, and hurling insults at Jeremy Corbyn, ironically as he called for a “safe space” from such behaviour during Prime Minister’s Questions.
The hypocrisy comes into sharp focus when one recalls that only two days before, Conservative MPs wrote to Metropolitan Police Commissioner Cressida Dick, demanding stronger policing of the area outside the Palace of Westminster to prevent abuse of the kind directed at Conservative MP Anna Soubry by (right-wing pro-Brexit) protesters on Monday.
Note that I put “right wing pro-Brexit” in parentheses because there seems to be a concerted effort to airbrush this fact out of the record, along with the abuse of left-wing journalist Owen Jones by the same people. We’ll come to that shortly.
First, let’s consider yesterday’s Parliamentary antics, starting with the Grieve Amendment. Tory backbencher and former Attorney General Dominic Grieve had proposed an amendment to legislation that gives the government 21 days to say what happens next if its Brexit deal is voted down, and a further seven sitting days (days in which Parliament is in session) in which to hold a vote.
The amendment reduces the time allowed before a statement is made to just three days. It isn’t binding, but it would be extremely damaging to Theresa May if she failed to do so.
MPs objected because they claimed the original legislation was unamendable. Mr Bercow held a different view:
And that his interpretation is that while there should be no debate, he can still select amendments, including inviting Grieve to put his. Hope that’s clear!
— Jane Merrick (@janemerrick23) January 9, 2019
Let’s see if I can dig out some examples of the behaviour he had to endure. Here’s Arj Singh:
“Sorry that is utter sophistry”, an absolutely fuming Tory MP shouts
— Arj Singh (@singharj) January 9, 2019
That’s mild. Try this:
Minor applause from opposition MPs for Bercow now who remains defiant
— Arj Singh (@singharj) January 9, 2019
Mr Clarke’s reference was to the right-wingers who abused Ms Soubry and Mr Jones, and hints as to the attitudes he saw being expressed around him.
Then we had the hypocrisy of the Leader of the House, Andrea Leadsom:
No denial from Bercow. Advice is “private”
— Arj Singh (@singharj) January 9, 2019
Given how hard Andrea Leadsom fought to keep the govt's legal advice on the Withdrawal Bill a secret, isn't it a bit, I dunno, hypocritical, for her to demand the confidential advice the speaker receives from his clerks be revealed for the first time in history?@lbc #bbcpm
— I Am Incorrigible also on Bluesky, threads & masto (@ImIncorrigible) January 9, 2019
Bercow very slippery on Clerk’s advice
— Arj Singh (@singharj) January 9, 2019
Here’s the icing on this particularly rotten cake – the moment when Tory MP Adam Holloway accused Mr Bercow of trying to sabotage Brexit, claiming as evidence that the Speaker has a pro-Remain sticker on his car. The slapdown was brilliant:
https://twitter.com/SidUnite/status/1083002551493189637
It seems clear that the behaviour of these Conservatives lowered the tone of debate in the Commons and arguably harmed the reputation of Parliament itself – although some would say that this cannot happen as they have already damaged it irreparably:
https://twitter.com/ArgyleLoz/status/1083008945948626944
The arguments over the Amendment were – sadly – only a sequel to a similar unseemly display during Prime Minister’s Questions.
Both Mrs May and Mr Corbyn mentioned the intimidation of Ms Soubry and Mr Jones on Monday. The prime minister said politicians and the media should be able to go about their work without harassment and intimidation.
Sadly, her backbenchers did not pay any attention to her (perhaps cementing our opinion that she is no leader) and poured abuse at Mr Corbyn while he agreed with her. He said: “We also have to be clear that intimidation is wrong outside this building as it is wrong in any other aspect of life in this country, and we have to create a safe space for political debate.”
By this point, the level of heckling had reached a point beyond which he could not continue, so he pointed it out: “You see what I mean, Mr Speaker; I am calling for a safe space for political debate.”
The Tory perpetrators may have enjoyed themselves but the public drew the appropriate conclusions, as the following comments bear out:
At #PMQs, the Tory benches shouting & braying as @jeremycorbyn calls for a safe space for political debate. Levels of self-awareness: zero.
— Ben Sellers (@MrBenSellers) January 9, 2019
Conservative MPs have spent the last 48 hours saying how its so horrible when politicians are shouted at in a way rude way yet they just spent #PMQs shouting at Jeremy Corbyn in the rudest way while he was trying to ask questions
There's a word for such behaviour: hypocrisy
— Shlomo (@hapoelorient) January 9, 2019
https://twitter.com/Wirral_In_It/status/1082976660322955264
And of course, that is what they have been trying to do.
Possibly worse than the habitually abusive behaviour of Tory MPs is the apparent attempt to pretend that the only person suffering abuse on College Green on Monday was Ms Soubry.
I myself was so surprised to see her mentioned on the BBC’s lunchtime Politics Live show – and not Owen Jones, who is a frequent panellist there – that I actually raised the matter with editor Rob Burley. Here’s the dialogue:
.@BBCPolitics why the exclusive concentration on abuse of .@Anna_Soubry on #PoliticsLive ? .@OwenJones84 was subjected to vile abuse by the same people, followed with threats of extreme violence on the social media. Why the silence about that?
— Mike Sivier (@MidWalesMike) January 8, 2019
Because we are a political programme and focused on the threat specifically to MPs. The abuse of Owen was nasty too – and appeared to be the same people – but our focus was politicians. https://t.co/aKKORyzMtH
— Rob Burley (@RobBurl) January 8, 2019
We are a political show and the subject we discussed was the abuse of MPs. This doesn’t mean we think others should be harassed but that our show focused on the abuse of MPs. https://t.co/K3Uz2D9qqL
— Rob Burley (@RobBurl) January 8, 2019
Disagree. There we are.
— Rob Burley (@RobBurl) January 8, 2019
But agree treatment of Owen disgraceful
— Rob Burley (@RobBurl) January 8, 2019
What do you think of that?
More concerning still were the efforts to mitigate the effect of Mr Burley’s choice – which was to play up the effect on Ms Soubry and play down that on Mr Jones – by members of the public. Here’s one such comment:
He's a journalist and a left-wing political activist who has already acknowledged that he wasn't bothered by the incident (see his own Tweet).
— Clive Briggs (@BriggsClive) January 8, 2019
Owen Jones himself put that comment in its place, in a response to information from Channel 4 News reporter Michael Crick that – as with the BBC – attempted to excise the abuse of Mr Jones from the record:
I extend my solidarity to Anna Soubry, but she wasn’t their only target. Given we’ve established the far right threaten Labour people and the left, and have killed a Labour MP, can we not airbrush the left from this please? https://t.co/1zI1Sg8ccd
— Owen Jones (@OwenJones84) January 8, 2019
Left-wing members of the public have made it clear that they are not going to accept this kind of misreporting from the mainstream media:
Just to clarify it was a right wing thug who was intimidating Anna Soubry & @OwenJones84.
Just to remind it was a right wing thug who killed Jo Cox.
Just to remind right wing activists/ trolls tweet nasty tweets to / about @HackneyAbbott, @DawnButlerBrent & other Left-wing MPs
— WeThePeople (@gaurangmorjaria) January 9, 2019
If you are confused as to the reason television news reporters have tried to play down the targeting of people who represent the Left by people who are for all intents and purposes fascists, I refer you to this perceptive comment by Mr Jones, that makes it clear that the mainstream media have legitimised it:
By denouncing their opponents as "terrorist supporters", "enemies of the people", "traitors" and demanding "saboteurs" are "crushed", the British press is fuelling the far right. pic.twitter.com/zwg03pkclO
— Owen Jones (@OwenJones84) January 8, 2019
The attitudes we have seen are sickening: Right-wing MPs have shown they are happy to abuse others before TV cameras in the Palace of Westminster, while decrying the same behaviour against their own by members of the public who were filmed on mobile phones, as their cronies in the mass media do their best to make it seem that they are the victims – when in fact they have stoked the extreme attitudes that lead to such abuse, threatening behaviour and, ultimately, violence.
These are our elected representatives but if this is how they conduct themselves, they do not represent me. We must demand better.
Visit our JustGiving page to help Vox Political’s Mike Sivier fight anti-Semitism libels in court
Vox Political needs your help!
If you want to support this site
(but don’t want to give your money to advertisers)
you can make a one-off donation here:
Here are four ways to be sure you’re among the first to know what’s going on.
1) Register with us by clicking on ‘Subscribe’ (in the left margin). You can then receive notifications of every new article that is posted here.
2) Follow VP on Twitter @VoxPolitical
3) Like the Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/VoxPolitical/
Join the Vox Political Facebook page.
4) You could even make Vox Political your homepage at http://voxpoliticalonline.com
And do share with your family and friends – so they don’t miss out!
If you have appreciated this article, don’t forget to share it using the buttons at the bottom of this page. Politics is about everybody – so let’s try to get everybody involved!
Buy Vox Political books so we can continue
fighting for the facts.
The Livingstone Presumption is now available
in either print or eBook format here:
Health Warning: Government! is now available
in either print or eBook format here:
The first collection, Strong Words and Hard Times,
is still available in either print or eBook format here:
The odious and loathsome Tories have always been able to dish out thoroughly dishonest sneering insults at will, but they can’t take even the slightest legitimate criticism directed at them.
Right wing, extreme right blah blah. Anyone who s supports Brexit is extreme right according to quasi Liberal blogs and rags.
According to whom? You? May we see your credentials and evidence please?