Rayner defies EHRC by threatening to suspend ‘thousands’ of Labour members
Note to Sienna Rodgers at LabourList: the headline on your report is wrong. It should have read Angela Rayner is a big ol’ hypocrite.
In the article, Rayner states that the findings of the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s report on anti-Semitism in the Labour Party are not open to debate:
There’s no debating what the EHRC said.
LabourList also reported another statement she made to the Jewish Labour Movement’s conference – insultingly held on the International Day of Solidarity with Palestinians – that she and Keir Starmer attended rather than support the Palestine solidarity event:
If I have to suspend thousands and thousands of members, we will do that.
The two comments are mutually exclusive. The report clearly states that
We have concluded that the practice of political interference was unlawful… The Labour Party should… implement clear rules and guidance that prohibit and sanction political interference in the complaints process.
Her threat to suspend thousands – a warning that the leadership is planning to purge the party of anybody who dissents against its dictatorship – is itself political interference in the process, as it is an attempt to suppress complaints by members against the actions of the leadership of which she is a member. Therefore she is not only debating the legitimacy of the EHRC’s finding; she is ignoring it altogether.
Remember that this is all about the attack on Jeremy Corbyn by Keir Starmer, party general secretary David Evans, and others at the very top of the Labour leadership including Rayner herself, despite the fact that she once said this:
This you, @AngelaRayner?
“If I felt that Jeremy Corbyn accepted that abuse in our party I wouldn’t be in it. I wouldn’t be in his shadow cabinet”
– Labour frontbencher Angela Rayner says Jeremy Corbyn has fought anti-Semitism and racism all his lifepic.twitter.com/S8UNE1TcBG
— James Foster (@JamesEFoster) November 29, 2020
She went from that position to saying that the truth is “unacceptable”:
Is @AngelaRayner really saying here that the truth is unacceptable?
Somebody tell me I’ve got that wrong?
I have got it wrong, haven’t I?
The truth, unacceptable? Surely not. https://t.co/a3mIHVEB8U
— James Foster (@JamesEFoster) November 29, 2020
She is a hypocrite. She has revealed her true colours. She cannot be trusted. She should be ejected from her position of power.
This will be hard because the Labour Party leadership has a well-known track record of rejecting any complaints against its own members and friends, no matter how well-justified they may be.
But we have all seen this behaviour and we are talking about it:
Big from @AngelaRayner as she seems to back suspending ‘thousands and thousands of members’ for wanting to demonstrate support for Jeremy Corbyn having the whip returned.
If MPs can state views publicly, why can’t members? https://t.co/XKoiR5vmax
— Aaron Bastani (@AaronBastani) November 29, 2020
This whole thing just shows the duplicity and shiftiness of those at the top of the Labour Party.
David Evans explicitly stated the disciplinary process against Corbyn is now over. What we now have is leaders doing the precise opposite of what the EHRC asks for, interfering. https://t.co/mK5JOtVyxZ
— Aaron Bastani (@AaronBastani) November 29, 2020
Yes, it's 'totally unacceptable' to say precisely what the EHRC report says you can say, and which you have the freedom of speech to say, and which is obviously and provably true, in case it upsets some right-wing bigots.
Bye, Labour. It's been fun. https://t.co/kPXxBX1rq2
— simon maginn (@simonmaginn) November 29, 2020
If this is what @AngelaRayner has said it is dishonest. CLPs are debating whether the whip should be reinstated to Jeremy Corbyn: that is about democratic procedure not antisemitism
Genuine Q: have any CLPs passed motions against EHRC report or that antisemitism isn't a problem? https://t.co/HryXTRFAWm
— Andrew Fisher (@FisherAndrew79) November 29, 2020
Could Rayner clarify what, if any, powers she has to suspend "thousands of members" and how her doing that conforms with the EHRC recommendation of an investigation and disciplinary process free of leadership intervention? https://t.co/0ekPF64aj3
— Devutopia (@D_Raval) November 29, 2020
Who is going to tell them?
Because they ain't listening to us, that's for sure. 😒
— MerryMichaelW ☭ 🎗 #Socialism #Equality 🇵🇸 (@MerryMichaelW) November 29, 2020
With one side of her mouth she spits vitriol at Corbyn for his comments in which he said the EHRC report should be implemented, & with the other she outright defies the EHRC report criticism of political interference in disciplinary cases, saying she'll personally suspend 1,000s! https://t.co/KTOd6IQtIE
— Another Angry Voice (@Angry_Voice) November 29, 2020
“It is not legitimate for the leadership to influence, make recommendations or make decisions on complaints.. The Labour Party needs to restore confidence in the independence of its complaints process”—EHRC
"If I have to suspend thousands & thousands of members…”—Angela Rayner https://t.co/vYzG1G8urK
— Alex Nunns (@alexnunns) November 29, 2020
So Rayner is saying 1000s and 1000s could be thrown out of the party,
She will be in for a shock them when she finds out 1000s and 1000s are already leaving the clusterfuck of a party
— Fanxxxxtastic-Trada (@Fanxxxxtastic) November 29, 2020
https://twitter.com/AmmarKazmi_/status/1333032337018400768
The Labour leadership are now deliberately shitting all over the recommendations of the EHRC report that they've used as an excuse to attack and vilify Jeremy Corbyn (despite the fact he said the EHRC recommendations should be implemented!).
Astounding hypocrisy https://t.co/enVVQKLIkw
— Another Angry Voice (@Angry_Voice) November 29, 2020
The Labour Party has become a complete farce. https://t.co/looQomqXhs
— CrémantCommunarde #BeAPeacemonger ☮️ (@0Calamity) November 29, 2020
There isn't thousands and thousands of antisemites in the party, @AngelaRayner . Corbyn was allowed to comment on the EHRC. He was allowed back to the party. If you fancy to play "I'm the dictator's best mate" go for it. But you showing who you really are and ppl won't forget it https://t.co/HxdFMpammj
— Audrey (@AudreyMagel) November 29, 2020
And organisations that formerly wanted Rayner’s support and endorsement are now rejecting her. To be honest, I don’t know if the following tweet was connected with what she said on LabourList, but I anticipate that this is the soft footfall that precedes a stampede:
What a massive let-down and huge sell-out @AngelaRayner turned out to be. Please remove your support from the LGBTQ+ community Angela. The oppressed stand with the oppressed, we don't stand with apartheid committing states, and we don't stand with traitors who ignore that.
— Robin 💚 (@HouseOfRedRobin) November 29, 2020
Oh, and by the way, Labour is not completely irredeemable. Members across the UK did come out in support of Palestine, unlike their treacherous leader and deputy leader. Here’s a tweet from Wales:
Well done to all across Wales who have taken the time to express solidarity with the Palestinian people, who continue to live in dire, oppressive circumstances under a brutal, right-wing Israeli government. 👇✊#palestineday #EndApartheid #StopAnnexation https://t.co/F85HpIQeXE
— Welsh Labour Grassroots (@WLGrassroots) November 28, 2020
Let’s remember that Rayner – and her vile boss Starmer – are saying that they are taking all this action against the good members of their own party because of hurt, harm and injury done to Jewish people in the UK.
What about the harm done to Jewish people who agree with the viewpoint Rayner, Starmer and the others are attacking?
Genuine question @AngelaRayner @Keir_Starmer will you meet urgently with representatives of the many Jews who support Corbyn and think you are getting this disastrously wrong?
If not, why not?By the way THESE Jews feel you are injuring THEM. Don’t these Jews count Keir, Angela? https://t.co/HeU48hgIbo
— Tom London (@TomLondon6) November 29, 2020
That’s right. These Jews feel that Rayner, Starmer and the others are attacking them. And Rayner, Starmer et al treat them as though they don’t even exist.
Isn’t that attitude a little… you know… anti-Semitic?
Finally, Labour’s deplorable leaders need to acknowledge that this confrontation between them and party members arose because the EHRC found that the leadership had been interfering in investigations of anti-Semitism complaints in order to make it seem that there were more anti-Semites in the party than was the case.
A court found only last week that the process of investigating accusations against This Writer – me, Mike Sivier – was perverted in order to produce a false finding against me.
Labour failed to follow its own investigation procedure. It did not adequately inform me of the nature of the allegations against me (in fact, the party changed those claims as it went on, in order to ‘fix’ the result), and a party officer leaked false claims about me – including a lie that I was a Holocaust denier – to The Sunday Times (which subsequently had to publish a lengthy correction).
And I’m not the only one who has suffered this treatment. The EHRC report found that, of the investigations it examined, no fewer than 60 per cent suffered from bias calculated to discriminate against the respondent – against the person accused of anti-Semitism.
Where are the apologies for lying and smearing us? I still receive abusive messages accusing me of anti-Semitism, even now. It may be that I will continue receiving them for the rest of my life. The Labour Party is to blame for that. Where is the contrition? Where is the apology for that?
I find Ms Rayner’s ‘I/we’ confusion to be compelling proof of her unfitness to serve us, whether as an MP or anything else.
Good riddance. Corbyn and his comrades get into bed with racist homophobic misogynistic baby-killer Hamas & Hezbollah, then bitch and moan when called to account. Screw them, the Falangists of the left.
Ladies and gentlemen, this is the kind of ignorance we must overcome.
Lou I must be in another planet your words against a man of principles you believe the crap stammer the spammer and his cohorts call real labour people’s it’s unbelievable I had hoped for better world for my children but with people like you I’m believing that only crap will come out of the joking labour party with stammer the spammer
Tony Blair paved the way for the likes of Starmer and Rayner with New Labour (a second establishment party). What opposition is Starmer to the Tories? None whatsoever. What has he had to say about this Coronavirus nonsense? He’s gone along with it.
We need Old Labour back – the party we had before these thieves stole it from us,
Both Rayner and Starmer need to have respect for the right of members to voice their opinions or face being voted out of the party at the first possible opportunity.
Corbyn gave Rayner and Starmer a position on his shadow front bench. This is how they repay him. Politics is indeed a dirty game isn’t it? That these two inveterate liars could lock themselves in a room and conspire to muddy the name of a thoroughly decent man by suspending him is ok with them?
They know darn well Corbyn is no racist, he’s the most decent man in politics today. His only crime was to speak up for the Palestinian people, something that lot, as MPs, should all be doing. But they won’t, because they’re all petrified of offending Israel and its criminal, racist, apartheid regime which murders women and children.
Shame on them all. They forget their roots, and the sense of moral righteousness which makes great politicians such as Corbyn. Where is their sympathy towards the Palestinian people, and the atrocities committed daily against them by Israel? They are zionists, and I will have no truck with that.