Why is turncoat Lord Warner still allowed to say he’s a LABOUR peer?

Odious old git: Lord Warner.

Odious old git: Lord Warner.

Calls for Maria Miller to resign have dominated the news this week, but there is one other person who should be ejected, if only from the political party they claim to represent.

That person is the closet Conservative, Lord Warner.

He is a man who has united with the right-wing thinktank, Reform, to demand that members of the public should pay £10 a month for NHS services, calling it a “suggested” “membership fee”.

It should come as no surprise that this odious old git has his claws very firmly into private healthcare and is only interested in lining his own pockets. That’s a Conservative attitude – not Labour.

Jacky Davis, co-editor of NHS SOS, writing in The Guardian, explains why Warner’s attitude is wrong: “Charges of this sort deter the poor and the elderly – the very people who need the NHS most – and as a result they present later with more advanced illness. To Warner and the pundits at Reform £120 a year may not look much, but it will feel like the last straw to those already struggling with the consequences of austerity. The public understand this and, as a recent survey shows, are overwhelmingly against upfront payments.

“The most efficient and the fairest way of funding it is through progressive central taxation.

“No politician with any sense would publicly endorse these proposals for charges, but nevertheless they have served their purpose: they have reinforced the myth that the NHS is “outdated and unaffordable”, and re-animated the zombie policy that it could be saved by upfront individual payments.”

To understand Lord Warner’s role, we need only look to former Deputy Prime Minister Lord Prescott’s column in the Mirror: “The professed Labour supporter’s call, in his pamphlet and a newspaper article, is in direct opposition to the principle of treatment based on need, not the ability to pay.

“He rules out further taxation to fund the £30 billion gap in funds for the NHS. Perhaps he could consider, for a similar amount of our money, scrapping future spending on the Trident nuclear deterrent.

“Lord Warner, a career civil servant, was actively involved in advising private healthcare firms who have lucrative contracts in the NHS.

“Last year he was the only Labour peer to vote with the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats on proposed NHS regulations to allow companies to bid for almost all health services.

“When he was called before a ­parliamentary select committee to discuss his lobbying as a peer for private ­healthcare, he said: ‘The point I’m trying to make is that we do not have constituents. There is not a group of people who have voted for us… We are not elected to represent a particular geographical area and we are not paid a salary.’

“But he was nominated by Labour to be one of its peers.

“Warner admitted he does not represent the people. Instead he speaks up for the private healthcare industry through his private consultancy firm Sage Advice Ltd.

“Labour created the NHS – against ardent opposition from the Tories – to make healthcare free at the point of delivery to anyone who needs it, not just those who can afford it.

“I fear the constant dismantling of the NHS by the ConDem coalition.

“But I also worry about people like Warner who use the Labour Red Flag as a flag of convenience to peddle the right’s privatisation agenda.

“I will fight tooth and nail with every last breath in my body to make sure his heartless and repugnant views are never made policy.”

Lord Prescott also made clear something that Tories like Warner tend to forget: The NHS already does charge people – “it’s called National Insurance and general taxation.”

Follow me on Twitter: @MidWalesMike

Join the Vox Political Facebook page.

Vox Political supports healthcare based on need, not the ability to pay
… but we need YOUR help.
This independent blog’s only funding comes from readers’ contributions.
Without YOUR help, we cannot keep going.
You can make a one-off donation here:

Donate Button with Credit Cards

Alternatively, you can buy the first Vox Political book,
Strong Words and Hard Times
in either print or eBook format here:


8 thoughts on “Why is turncoat Lord Warner still allowed to say he’s a LABOUR peer?

  1. pippakin

    Reblogged this on Political Pip Spit or Swallow its up to You and commented:
    I think Lord Muck Warner has forgotten that everyone does already pay for the NHS this is a cynical and shameless attempt to increase National Insurance by the back door. it will also limit NHS availability to those in most need.

    Successive govts have been abusing the NHS for years its long past time they stopped.

  2. Pingback: Why is turncoat Lord Warner still allowed to sa...

  3. beastrabban

    Reblogged this on Beastrabban’s Weblog and commented:
    Warner should be thrown out of the Labour party for his advocacy of the privatisation of the NHS. As for his statement that he doesn’t have any constituents, and nobody voted for him, that invites the response Winston Churchill once said of another member of the House of Lords: ‘The Honourable Member represents only himself, and I don’t like his constituency’. It also acts as a very powerful argument for complete reform of the House of Lords and its replacement with an elected Upper House.

  4. jeffrey davies

    yet there are more tony blaires within this party with maggies help he took labour so far right its now a little tory party has to the lord they made him they can take it away also jeff3

Comments are closed.