DWP’s letter to doctors means MORE people have been wrongly denied benefits

Sarah Newton: The Conservative minister for disabled people once said there was no “hostile environment” for benefit claimants. Her capacity for inaccuracy, thus demonstrated, seems to be proved again with this case.

The duplicity in the latest attack on the sick and disabled by the Conservatives is enough to make anybody ill – including the doctors it targeted.

People claiming Employment and Support Allowance because they are too unwell to work, but who have their claim turned down by assessors from the private company hired by the Department for Work and Pensions, are entitled to receive the benefit while they await their appeal hearing.

But they need ‘fit’ notes from their doctors, to prove they are too ill to work – and it has emerged that “ministers” (we don’t know which) have ordered changes to the standard letter sent to GPs, in order to make them think these notes are not necessary.

It’s clearly a scam to undermine the law; sick people can’t receive the benefit if they don’t have a note from their GP, so the government has told GPs to stop providing these notes.

Amazingly, the DWP has claimed that the removal of references that made it clear to GPs they may have to issue a medical statement if their patient wished to appeal against a WCA decision was not intended to dissuade GPs from issuing fit notes.

In that case, why change the letter at all?

And why are we told that the wording was changed by agreement with the British Medical Association and the Royal College of General Practitioners (although it is significant that there appear to be no formal minutes of the meeting at which this agreement was made)?

According to The Guardian:

The standard letter, called an ESA65B, is sent automatically to the GPs of all claimants who fail a WCA and are declared fit enough to work. Until 2017 the letter advised GPs that if their patient appealed against the WCA decision they must continue to provide fit notes.

However, on ministers’ orders, the letter now states that GPs “do not need to provide any more fit notes for ESA purposes”. It does not mention the possibility that the patient may appeal, or that a fit note is needed for the patient to obtain ESA payments until the appeal is heard.

And what has been the result? Back to the Graun:

Advice charity Z2K said the effect of the revised letter could be devastating. “We have seen how our clients, who are seriously ill, suddenly have zero income, become reliant on food bank vouchers and loans, and face a very real threat of homelessness.”

There was national outrage over the case of Stephen Smith, 64, who was deemed fit for work despite suffering from multiple debilitating illnesses, having his weight plummet to 38kg (6 stone) and being barely able to walk. Smith won his appeal after waiting 12 months for a hearing.

Prof Helen Stokes-Lampard, the chair of the Royal College of GPs (RCGP), said the lack of clarity over when GPs should issue fit notes could put patients’ finances and health at risk.

The reason for the change is obvious – it is well-known that 72% of claimants who appeal against their Work Capability Assessment decision are successful.

As readers of This Site know, the Conservatives like to persecute people with long-term illnesses and disabilities to their deaths. So they are trying to make it impossible for claimants to survive long enough to win their appeals.

It seems former minister for disabled people, Sarah Newton (ah, so that’s her name! I had forgotten it already) may have ordered the change. She certainly protested to the Work and Pensions select committee that the change had been to make the letter “simpler and clearer”.

Committee chair Frank Field’s acid reply was that the wording was “not having its desired effect”.

Do you think the DWP will change it back?

Source: ‘Misleading’ DWP letter causing ill and disabled people to lose benefits | Society | The Guardian

Vox Political needs your help!
If you want to support this site
but don’t want to give your money to advertisers)
you can make a one-off donation here:

Donate Button with Credit Cards

Here are four ways to be sure you’re among the first to know what’s going on.

1) Register with us by clicking on ‘Subscribe’ (in the left margin). You can then receive notifications of every new article that is posted here.

2) Follow VP on Twitter @VoxPolitical

3) Like the Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/VoxPolitical/

Join the Vox Political Facebook page.

4) You could even make Vox Political your homepage at http://voxpoliticalonline.com

And do share with your family and friends – so they don’t miss out!

If you have appreciated this article, don’t forget to share it using the buttons at the bottom of this page. Politics is about everybody – so let’s try to get everybody involved!

Buy Vox Political books so we can continue
fighting for the facts.

The Livingstone Presumption is now available
in either print or eBook format here:

HWG PrintHWG eBook

Health Warning: Government! is now available
in either print or eBook format here:

HWG PrintHWG eBook

The first collection, Strong Words and Hard Times,
is still available in either print or eBook format here:


6 thoughts on “DWP’s letter to doctors means MORE people have been wrongly denied benefits

  1. Debbie Wiles

    Having recently lost my PIP (due to a list of lies and assumptions – did you know that using a computer and having a driving license as your primary photo ID go against you, or that walking a couple of steps forward and back to your wheelchair are evidence that you can repeatedly and safely walk 200 meters? I do now!), I am dreading the response to my WCA forms.

  2. loonytoonz

    Going by “dearest” Amber’s reply to a question about it yesterday……. I think the honest answer is a resounding NO.
    I will have to try and get a constituency surgery appointment with her…. She can answer as well why when there is an assessment center locally, atos or whatever they’re calling themselves now, are trying to send me a 2 hr journey by public transport each way, for a PIP assessment!

  3. Michael McNulty

    The doublespeak shows the authoritarian nature of this Tory policy. Ignorance is Strength. War is Peace. Sick note is Fit note.

  4. carolyn adams

    the sick infirm and disabled have suffered at the hands of the tories, not one rise in line with inflation since the ConDems took over over No. 10, yet gas electric water ect have tripled since the austerity lies started, How many pay rises have they given themselves over the years, now l find every last one of the voted to end free school meals, hmmmmm yet in that shame of a building ,where they ‘debate’ there is always real posh foods for free, back-handers to fill their pockets, poop l wish l was Guye Fawlks lmao

  5. Jessie Saunders

    In December 2018 My wife had an operation, and as a result had to be off work for 10 weeks. My wife works 8 hours a week because of her disabilities. And is only claiming PIP payments.
    Because of the number of hours worked her employer issued a SSP1 FORM.(Supplementary Sick pay.) Which we had to take to the Job Center who gave us a telephone number for Universal Credits. Who sent us a claim form for the new style ESA. WHICH HAD TO BE A JOINT CLAIM.
    As my wifes National Insurance is her own responsibility as is mine and are two entirely personal items.
    My wife is over 60 and is now excluded from paying National insurance as her earning are to low.
    The Universal credits sent us a letter stating that they are not going to pay us Universal credits.
    When I telephoned them to explain that it was just the sick pay we were requiring for this 10 weeks and not Universal Credits as my pension and sick pay is pre paid for each week or each month by deductions from your pay as required under the NATIONAL INSURANCE ACT 1946. And are not benefits but Insurance payments.
    It looks as if the Government is neglecting the 1946 act and not complying with the DUTY OF CARE for vulnerable adults.
    yours truly.

Comments are closed.