Starmer has screwed up. Let’s put him on probation

Last Updated: November 22, 2025By

Share this post:

Keir Starmer has spent the first 16 months of his Parliament treading water (badly) and now wants us to give him another 44 months and a general election to put it right. I say no.

But I’m not saying he should be jettisoned just yet, either.

Let’s put him on probation.

Look at it this way: Starmer asked to be judged at the next general election, and that’s a reasonable democratic position — but the evidence in the Institute for Government’s (IfG) performance tracker report – and recent polling – means he should earn that mandate by demonstrating concrete, measurable delivery in a much shorter window.

To read the rest, head over to The Whip Line.

A subscription unlocks all my analysis and helps keep independent UK political journalism going.

Share this post:

2 Comments

  1. Martyn November 23, 2025 at 1:56 pm - Reply

    better still put him in prison for treason !

    • Mike Sivier November 23, 2025 at 6:57 pm - Reply

      “Treason” doesn’t apply here — and shouting it at Keir Starmer only distracts from the real problems with what he’s doing.

      Starmer isn’t guilty of betraying the monarch or aiding an enemy of the UK — that’s what treason actually means in law. But he is guilty of something politically serious: pushing through decisions that undermine civil liberties, criminalise legitimate dissent, and stretch government power far beyond what’s justified.

      Those are real, concrete issues we can hold him to account for — and they matter far more than throwing around a word that doesn’t fit the situation.

Leave A Comment